10

Can referees change their decision? What do you think about this question and its answers? Vote and comment to let everyone know.


6

Thank you everyone for casting your votes and leaving your comments. :) Here are some of mine: While there are some issues with traffic and user retention, the biggest problem I can see right now in this evaluation are the types of questions and answers you're putting forth. On a site with a wide scope, you're ending up with easy questions that are ...


4

I think it is on topic. It is a situation directly related to Sports that is not unique to OP with a solution that, while not "factual" in the explicit sense, would be relevant to other people.


4

Unless the signature is pretty well known, it's very difficult to play detective and positively identify an autograph. Especially when few clues are provided to start from. If some level of detail is provided - time period and team perhaps - then it seems like it would be OK to leave the question opened and hope that maybe someone will come along that can ...


3

We did see a spike in views and visitors during the Olympic season (down there to the right): That is very promising for the prospect of future promotions. The trick now is to boost your retention rate by keeping the quality high and doing a bit of patient hand-holding and education with your first-time users. The Role of niceness in a Q&A


3

Calculations of bat speed and pace of a delivery What do you think about this question and its answers? Vote and comment to let everyone know.


3

In college sports, why is permission needed to recruit other coaches? What do you think about this question and its answers? Vote and comment to let everyone know.


3

Why do players enter with children on the ground? What do you think about this question and its answers? Vote and comment to let everyone know.


2

Obviously I think it's on topic, but am aware that it is unusual, hence the comment I left when I posted the question. I think it is on topic because it is a question that is likely to come up for 'participants and observers of team and individual sport activities', whether the participant is the one making the decisions or the one affected by those ...


2

I disagree with this answer on the grounds that this post (on hold) features a clearly identifiable Willie Stargell autograph. Willie Stargell is a very famous, HOF baseball player from the 60's and 70's, and that ball may be worth some money. Although many of the posts do not have context, it is still possible that people can identify an autograph. ...


1

Excerpt from the FAQ section about what a good answer is: Is it supported by "authority?" Back up claims by referencing sources. This is particularly important when discussing rules. Can I provide a unique perspective? Add something new. If you have insight to add to another user's answer, consider doing so in a comment. Can I share my personal ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible