Search Results

In my opinion, swimming, running, weightlifting, etc. are not primarily sports. Questions about them should be limited to questions very specifically about the sport itself - the rules, for example. …

My general feeling on these are that they're fine, mostly because they're oftentimes the most interesting questions we have... but they're definitely something that can vary as far as quality. I'm not …

I didn't vote on the question, and don't really know much about it, but a few details that might suggest why it was downvoted. First, it's not really clear what you're asking. This may be a language …

I would not phrase my answer as suggesting "sometimes acceptable, sometimes not". My answer was that it is generally not acceptable, but we occasionally make exceptions - think 99% not, 1% yes. In th …

My opinion on that question is that it shouldn't have been modified. The rationale to modifying it was "to allow an answer to be chosen right", but there wouldn't have been any reason not to choose a …

I think there are three separate questions. Are there any questions that would be tagged fantasy that are on-topic? In particular, questions like this one, which aren't about fantasy per se but are …

I think that yes, within limits, questions like this should be on topic. Questions that ask where to find certain kinds of information - whether that be like the question at hand here, asking where t …

It can never be anything but a discussion/opinion question. (So "Too Broad" or "Primarily Opinion Based" are both good reasons here.) …

Most of this comes from the Moderators Pro Tempore question edit history, for those curious. February 2012: Site opens in public beta. March 2012: Michael Myers, Tonny Madsen, and Jamauss are appoint …

You can look at Catija's post here to see an example of some of the things that sites can customize. However, we have not yet had our "site design" phase yet, and likely won't for a long time (we're a …

Comment deletion by moderators can be viewed by moderators (or above, of course). However, for the most part comments are always subject to arbitrary deletion; they are not intended to persist nor to …

Yes, we should allow fantasy questions, as long as they are about how to play fantasy, the rules of fantasy sports, types of fantasy, or high level strategies. Tactics, meaning which player to start, …

No, we should continue to consider Fantasy questions off-topic on this site. The community would prefer to consider only questions that are directly applicable to actual sports; fantasy sports questi …

If there was an issue with the tone of their answers that generated that stream, and it was up to me to handle after discussion with the other mods, I would bring it up in a private chat with them, mentioning … If they continue using an inappropriate tone, then (after discussion with the mod team, and possibly with a CM) I would support suspending them to make it clear that they need to change. …

Thanks to everyone for voting - the activity is great to see! Congratulations to my fellow moderators Nij and Philip. Dly and Olaf, I hope to see you around doing all the great moderating you're alr …