Our last 7 autograph-identification questions (3 have been since deleted) have provided no detail toward helping to identify the autograph. These questions have been generally received well here, but since 11 out of 22 (7 out of 17 excluding deleted questions) of our autograph-identification questions have fallen under the category of "provided no detail," our reception may need reassessed.
What stands out are the differences in how these questions have been handled. Some have at least 3 upvotes. Some have a negative score. Two have been closed (then abandoned/deleted). Two have been deleted as dead.
Unless I'm missing something, each of these questions provided no more detail among the others. I didn't include questions that make an attempt to provide detail, for example:
How do we handle autograph-identification questions with no detail? I personally have been downvoting these questions.
Current questions with no detail:
Questions that were closed:
Questions that were deleted as dead: